Microsoft Internally Criticizes Its Day-One Game Pass Strategy As A Failed Bet

Expert Verified By

The Company Thought The Service Was Hurting Revenue And Cannibalising Sales.

Story Highlight
  • The decision to release AAA first-party titles day one on Game Pass has received internal criticism at Microsoft.
  • The company thinks this strategy is hurting revenue and cannibalising sales.
  • Many at Microsoft have opposed this move, saying it’s more profitable for the players.

Xbox has once again become the centerpiece of industry drama after laying off over 3,000 employees and gutting almost every studio under its wing. Multiple developers owned by the company have gone independent, while AAA studios like Obsidian and id Software have lost a sizable amount of staff to make up for losses.

Game Pass has come under renewed scrutiny following the job cuts, with Asha Sharma admitting that the service did not add meaningful growth to Xbox. As it turns out, Game Pass has become even more controversial internally, as Microsoft doesn’t like one of its hallmark features.

Why it matters: Analysts and developers have been reiterating that Game Pass does cannibalise sales to a sizable extent. Microsoft realising this so late is a failure on its end. 

call of duty game pass
Microsoft is against putting first-party titles like Call of Duty on Game Pass.

As reported by Bloomberg, Microsoft internally criticised the decision to release first-party AAA games on Xbox Game Pass on day one at no extra cost. Former employees working at the company stated that the strategy caused internal disagreements at Microsoft, with many opposing the model.

According to sources, many believed that day-one Game Pass launches were hurting revenue as fans would just subscribe to the service instead of paying the full $70 price. Hence, the strategy was more profitable for players while reducing sales of the AAA titles produced by Xbox.

The report only confirms what analysts have told us previously, with estimates revealing that Game Pass lost Call of Duty $300 million in revenue while hurting the sales of every title in its catalogue by a whopping 80%.

Xbox Game Pass Drop
The subscription service reduces the sales of the titles in its catalogue by 80%.

Furthermore, considering how the service has lost millions of followers since the Activision merger, Microsoft may have a point in bashing a business model that is cannibalising sales while falling short of its expected subscriber total by over 50%.

However, with Xbox no longer allowing Call of Duty titles on Game Pass day one, it does feel like the company has learned from its mistake. 

Do you think Xbox shouldn’t put its first-party AAA titles on the Game Pass day one? Does this practice cannibalise sales? Tell us in the comments below or head to the Tech4Gamers forum for discussion.

Was our article helpful? 👨‍💻

Thank you! Please share your positive feedback. 🔋

How could we improve this post? Please Help us. 😔

Gear Up For Latest News

Get exclusive gaming & tech news before it drops. Sign up today!

Join Our Community

Still having issues? Join the Tech4Gamers Forum for expert help and community support!

Latest News

Join Our Community

104,000FansLike
32,122FollowersFollow

Trending

Intergalactic Delay Could Push Budget Beyond $600 Million, Says Insider

Naughty Dog's Intergalactic could end up becoming one of the most expensive game to date if it ends up being delayed beyond 2027.

Control Resonant To Offer At Least 30 Hours of Gameplay

Remedy's Control Resonant might offer up to 50 hours of gameplay, but gamers can expect the main story to last at least 30 hours.

Xbox Hardware Revenue Falls By 29% In Latest Fiscal Year After Price Hikes

In its Fiscal Year 2026 report, Xbox revealed that hardware revenue dropped by a whopping 29% compared to FY25.

Halo Campaign Evolved Launches To Lowest Series Player Count on Steam

Halo Campaign Evolved's full Steam release has been met with a disappointing peak player count on Steam so far.

Fable Could be Xbox’s Last Attempt At A Major Day 1 Release on Game Pass

A new report suggests that Xbox could pivot away from day 1 Game Pass launches, and Fable could be its last attempt at a major release.