The Game Awards are always exciting for the fans as they stir discussions among passionate fans. This year, the inclusion of Resident Evil 4 Remake in the Game of The Year category sparked a debate.
Should remakes qualify for the Game of the Year award? Opinions vary widely, revealing the challenge of assessing revamped classics in a gaming world mostly focused on original titles.
Why it matters: Including remakes in the most prestigious category is a bit controversial, as it may overlook more deserving original titles. For instance, Hogwarts Legacy, an original title, was not nominated for any category despite its popularity.
Maybe a hot take but I don't think remakes should be nominated for GotY. I thought RE4 was a 5/5 game but it's weird to me that a remake takes priority for a nomination over a new game.
— FightinCowboy (@Fightincowboy) November 13, 2023
The Game of the Year nominees are out, featuring many great games of 2023. But it’s the remake of the 2005 classic Resident Evil 4 that’s sparking a heated discussion on social media.
Twitter users like FightinCowboy sparked a discussion among the gaming community with their tweets. Their view stems from the idea that favoring remakes over brand-new games might block the spotlight from shining on creative and original titles at the Game Awards.
The tweet got a lot of support, with over 3,200 likes, stirring up an ongoing debate. However, the discourse unfolds with a user countering the argument, asserting that Resident Evil 4 Remake offers a new gaming experience, making it a legitimate contender for the award.
The idea that a remake is a new project, especially considering the comprehensive overhaul in mechanics and gameplay, finds support from another user. They suggest the possibility of a separate category for remakes while still acknowledging their deserving recognition.
Seen some complaints about Resident Evil 4 Remake being nominated for Game of The Year just because it's a Remake!
IMO it does enough differently to not only pay homage to the original but also to stand out on its own! It's a fantastic game and is worth the nomination! pic.twitter.com/aQ2yYeZKM6
— 𝐑𝐮𝐥𝐞𝐓𝐢𝐦𝐞 (@RuleTimeSpace) November 15, 2023
However, a significant number of people agree with the original tweet that remakes certainly impede the popularity of new titles.
One user stated that players can have fun with remakes, but that doesn’t mean they deserve to be nominated for the Game of the Year. This perspective comes from a user who enjoyed the Dead Space remake but didn’t consider it a contender for this award.
Amidst the ongoing debate, a clear agreement seems hard to reach. This has led to the community pondering over the necessity of new award categories and clearer distinctions between original releases and their remake versions.
Resident Evil 4 Remake being nominated this year sets a precedent for acknowledging modernized classics. Yet, the community is split on whether this is a positive shift or a signal for the industry to rethink the Game Awards categories.
In the next few years, The Game Awards might change to keep up with the industry. We’ll have to wait and see if games like Final Fantasy 7 Rebirth follow Resident Evil 4’s lead.
Thank you! Please share your positive feedback. 🔋
How could we improve this post? Please Help us. 😔
Passionate gamer and content creator with vast knowledge of video games, and I enjoy writing content about them. My creativity and ability to think outside the box allow me to approach gaming uniquely. With my dedication to gaming and content creation, I’m constantly exploring new ways to share my passion with others.