The Top 5 Best-Rated Xbox Games of 2023

No Xbox Exclusive In Top 5!

Xbox fans were quite happy with everything Microsoft offered in 2023. From shadow drops like Hi-Fi Rush to big exclusives like Starfield, the current-gen Xbox consoles came into their own last year.

Most of the year’s best games, barring a few exclusives, were available on all platforms, so gamers playing exclusively on one or the other platform did not miss out on much.

Meanwhile, Game Pass offered 50 day-one titles, enticing millions toward the Xbox subscription service. Overall, there was no shortage of highly-rated games to play in the last 12 months, and we have combined a list of the highest-rated games on the platform to help you catch up on the best releases on the Xbox consoles.

1. Alan Wake 2

Alan Wake 2 Xbox Series S|X Metacritic Score
Source: Metacritic

First up is Remedy Entertainment’s latest release. Alan Wake 2 made the bold decision to stray away from its predecessor’s approach, using exemplary horror games like Resident Evil 2 for inspiration.

The result? A confident title that combines elements of mystery, exploration, and unparalleled atmosphere with groundbreaking visuals. Alan Wake 2 is also among the few games that best highlight the advantages of the Xbox Series X over other consoles, making it worth picking up for Xbox owners.

2. Diablo 4

Diablo 4 Xbox Series S|X Metacritic Score
Source: Metacritic

Microsoft’s only first-party game on the list comes in second place. Diablo 4, launched as a multiplatform game from Blizzard in mid-2023, now falls under the Xbox first-party division after the gaming giant acquired Activision Blizzard.

With a rating of 91/100 on Metacritic, this game came out swinging, launching to positive reviews from nearly every critic and record-breaking figures. While future updates proved divisive and fans began to lose some interest over time, Diablo 4 remains one of the finest releases on Xbox Series S|X, especially for fans of ARPGs.

3. Resident Evil 4

Resident Evil 4 Xbox Series S|X Metacritic Score
Source: Metacritic

Capcom’s latest remake was among the best-rated releases of 2023 on both PlayStation and Xbox consoles. Having sold over 5 million units, this remake has garnered praise for keeping the spirit of the original game intact while rejuvenating the entry with modern visuals and gameplay.

On Xbox Series S|X, Resident Evil 4 supports 60FPS gameplay and ray tracing. Capcom has also released more content for the remake in the form of Separate Ways, improving the overall survival-horror package.

4. Cyberpunk 2077 Phantom Liberty

Cyberpunk 2077 Phantom Liberty Xbox Series S|X Metacritic
Source: Metacritic

There is hardly a need to introduce Cyberpunk 2077 and its tale of redemption. Phantom Liberty has elevated this RPG experience, becoming a major financial success for CD Projekt RED.

Having scored 91/100 on Metacritic, the expansion’s release shows a stark contrast over the 2020 launch of Cyberpunk 2077. Today, this RPG offers hundreds of hours of content, industry-leading visuals for an open-world game, and sci-fi lore that should be enough to keep players engaged for the duration of its runtime.

5. Street Fighter 6

Street Fighter 6 Xbox Series S|X Metacritic Score
Source: Metacritic

Capcom’s biggest fighting game series returned to the spotlight with a new entry last year. Applauded for its accessibility features, in-depth training mode, and gimmicky yet entertaining World Tour mode, the game is already in a much better state than its predecessor.

Though Xbox fans had options like Mortal Kombat 1 available this year, no other modern title offers a 2D fighting game experience quite like Street Fighter 6 in 2023.

While these picks represent the best games by critic ratings, we recommended checking out a few other games from Xbox, too. Hi-Fi Rush, in particular, surprised us and earned a recommendation in no time.

Lies of P was another excellent day-one Game Pass release, and Starfield is worth trying solely for the fact that it served as Microsoft’s biggest first-party release of 2023. Fans of racing games should also consider trying Forza Motorsport despite its glaring weaknesses.

Baldur’s Gate 3 didn’t make the list due to limited reviews on the platform, but as the Game of the Year winner, it is certainly worth a mention as well.

Latest News

Follow Us



Superman Deserves New AAA Game On Par With Batman Arkham Series

Despite the character's popularity, DC hasn't made an AAA Superman game that serves as the definitive adaptation of the character.

Suicide Squad Proves That Live-Service Trend Chasing Needs To Stop

After the recent failure of Suicide Squad: Kill the Justice League, I think it's time for developers to stop chasing the live service trend.

Bioshock’s Art Deco Style & Atmosphere Remain Timeless 16 Years Later

Launched in 2007, Bioshock features some of gaming's most impressive visual art that was inspired by the 20th century's Art Deco.

Elden Ring Expansion’s $40 Price Tag Is Not A Red Flag

The first trailer of Elden Ring's new expansion, Shadow of the Erdtree, shows FromSoftware's work on the biggest DLC to date.

Helldivers 2 & Palworld Show Cheaper Games Can Easily Rival $70 Releases

Games such as Palworld and Helldivers 2 are easily outselling $70 releases, which shows that the industry needs to change its direction.