Game Devs Slam Xbox’s Muse Generative AI: ‘We’re Losing Craft’

Expert Verified By

AI Integration Means Another Wave Of Layoffs!

Story Highlight
  • Xbox’s generative AI model Muse is being poorly received by the public.
  • Developers have spoken against the AI model, saying that it aims to cut development cost
  • Another anonymous developer says Xbox doesn’t care if nobody wants this but still wants to proceed.

The whole concept of AI integration has been highly controversial when discussing integration with any art form. Video Games are just the most recent industry in which AI push is being normalized.

Just recently, Xbox announced its generative AI model called ‘Muse,’ which will help with game preservation and can generate gameplay. The model was based on Ninja Theory and Xbox’s collaboration with Bleeding Edge’s 7-years worth of gameplay.

Video game developers have also spoken in this regard and have some harsh words to say about Muse. 

Why it matters: The public verdict on Muse has been quite harsh, with people saying that they want machines to disrupt video games’ artistic aspects.

dev response muse ai
Veteran Industry Developer Responding To Xbox’s Muse Generative AI || Source: X

David Goldfarb, a veteran developer who worked on games like Battlefield 3, Payday 2, and more, replied with this.

Continuing this conversation with The Wired, David said that executives believe that AI is good for gaming because it helps reduce the development cost. 

The primary issue is that we are losing craft, — When we rely on this stuff we are implicitly empowering a class of people who own these tools and don’t give a f**k about how they reshape our lives

AAA video game development is costing way too much for a subpar result. On the other hand, smaller studios perfectly utilize their smaller budget, delivering AA titles outshining bigger releases.

Kingdom Come Deliverance 2
Kingdom Come Deliverance 2 Sales Are Impressive For A Game That Cost $40 Million To Develop

There are numerous other ways to reduce the cost of game development, and AI coding isn’t the answer. The last thing we need is another wave of layoffs in the gaming industry, which is already a worrying problem.

internal discussions about these sorts of things are quiet because EVERYONE fears being against this and losing their jobs due to the tumultuous time in our industry

In the same interview, a AAA developer who chooses to stay anonymous shared their thoughts on Muse, as they are not allowed to speak about it publicly.

Do you think AI integration can benefit video game development? Let us know in the comments below or join the discussion at the Tech4Gamers Forums.

Was our article helpful? 👨‍💻

Thank you! Please share your positive feedback. 🔋

How could we improve this post? Please Help us. 😔

Gear Up For Latest News

Get exclusive gaming & tech news before it drops. Sign up today!

Join Our Community

Still having issues? Join the Tech4Gamers Forum for expert help and community support!

Latest News

Join Our Community

104,000FansLike
32,122FollowersFollow

Trending

GTA 6 NPCs Are AT Least 10 Years Ahead Of Every Other Studio In The Industry, Says 007 Dev

According to A 007: First Light developer, the NPC technology being used in GTA 6 is at least 10 years ahead of everyone else.

GTA 6 Introducing “Criminal Profiling” To Combat Red Dead Redemption 2’s Honor System

Criminal profiling will be the new honor system in GTA 6, affecting gameplay based on how efficiently players commit crimes.

GTA 6 To Feature In-Depth Gym Mechanics, Working Out To Greatly Benefit Playthrough

New GTA 6 details have revealed it will feature realistic and in-depth gym mechanics, and working out will greatly alter your playthrough.

GTA 6 Features 600,000 Unique NPC Animations; 10x The Amount Featured In GTA 5

Rockstar Games says that GTA 6 NPCs have over 600,000 unique animations, marking a 10x increase over GTA 5's animations.

GTA 6 Map Is 2x The Size of GTA 5, And A Whopping 3x The Size of RDR 2

The GTA 6 map is enormous and will be double the size of GTA 5, with Vice City also being 2x the size of Los Santos.