Threads
- Hyperrealistic graphics can be costly and risky, often leading to financial losses for studios.
- Stylized games age better and enhance storytelling more than realism, as seen with Wind Waker, Persona 5, etc.
- Art style directly impacts gameplay and immersion, proving creativity is more important than graphical fidelity alone.
Video games have come a long way, and graphics cards have played a major role in their evolution. Gamers have different thoughts on whether hyper-realistic graphics make a game better or a unique art style. Realism closely mimics the real world, while creative art focuses on unique styles and imaginative designs.
As AAA developers have chased hyper-realistic visuals in recent years, many gamers have turned to indie titles for their storytelling and creative art. The reason why creative art direction is more important than pure realism is because it remains visually appealing for years and stands out from the crowd.
Realism Can Be Expensive And Risky
Creating a game with hyper-realistic graphics requires significant investment in marketing, development, time, and resources. Big companies like Rockstar can afford to spend heavily to create lifelike worlds, as seen in Red Dead Redemption 2, which remains one of the most highly regarded games years after its release.
However, not every studio can develop such games due to budget constraints. Attempting to achieve high realism without enough resources can lead to major economic loss. For example, Immortals of Aveum had poor sales, which forced the studio to lay off 50% of its staff just a month after release.
Moreover, hyper-realistic games often lack creativity, are released with bugs, and sometimes are launched unfinished. In contrast, games with unique art styles prioritize artistic creativity, allowing developers to create memorable visuals even with limited resources.
Marvel’s Avengers is a perfect example of the risks of prioritizing realism over creativity. Despite its massive budget, the game’s realistic graphics felt lifeless, the environments felt repetitive, and it failed to impress the community visually. As a result, the game was eventually removed from all digital platforms.
Another example is Concord, a paid hero shooter by Sony that became a disaster within weeks of its release. Competition from free-to-play rivals, an uninspired art style, and repetitive gameplay led to the game’s failure and significant financial loss for the company.
Why Unique Art Style Is Important In Gaming
One major issue with hyper-realistic games is that they don’t age well. As technology advances, what looks realistic today may seem outdated in just a few years. For instance, when The Witcher 3 was released, its visuals were groundbreaking, but they now feel less impressive than modern games.
In contrast, stylized games rely on artistic expression rather than technological power, giving them a timeless quality. For example, in The Legend of Zelda: The Wind Waker. When it was released, some critics disliked its cartoon-like graphics, but years later, people’s opinions have changed due to the game’s unique design.
Moreover, unique art styles bring characters and worlds to life more meaningfully. Realistic games sometimes feel mechanical, focusing more on accuracy than creating a strong emotional connection with players.
Art style is a crucial part of a game’s identity. Even in superhero games, stylized art has proven to be more engaging. For example, Marvel Rivals features the same characters as Marvel’s Avengers. Still, instead of dull realism, it uses bold colors, expressive designs, and cel-shaded graphics, making it stand out in the gaming community.
How Art Style Shapes Gameplay
Many realistic games feel repetitive and uninspired. In contrast, stylized games allow developers to create entirely new worlds. Games like BioShock and Persona 5 use bold artistic choices to craft immersive, one-of-a-kind experiences.
Stylized games feel more inspired and engaging. Take Borderlands, for example; it uses a comic book-style cel-shaded art direction. While other shooters opt for ultra-realism, Borderlands stands out with its hand-drawn textures and exaggerated character designs, giving it a unique identity.
Hyper-realism can succeed only when executed well. Players appreciate realistic visuals, as seen with Rockstar’s upcoming GTA VI, one of the year’s most anticipated games. However, not all games are well-made, often leading to major losses. That’s why gaming studios should prioritize storytelling over chasing hyper-realistic graphics.
Creative art direction is now essential to what makes a game special. If developers want their games to stand out and remain beloved for years, embracing creative art direction is the way forward.
Thank you! Please share your positive feedback. 🔋
How could we improve this post? Please Help us. 😔
[Comparisons Expert]
Shehryar Khan, a seasoned PC hardware expert, brings over three years of extensive experience and a deep passion for the world of technology. With a love for building PCs and a genuine enthusiasm for exploring the latest advancements in components, his expertise shines through his work and dedication towards this field. Currently, Shehryar is rocking a custom loop setup for his built.
Get In Touch: shehryar@tech4gamers.com
Join Our Community
