Are Mechanical Keyboard Much Better Than Membrane Ones?

See full bio

Abdul Hannan

As Tech4Gamers’ editor, I leverage years of hardware exploration to provide nuanced insights. Stay updated with the latest in gaming and tech through my perspective.

See full bio

The common consensus is that certain circumstances aside, mechanical keyboards always have an edge over membrane ones. While that’s certainly true in most cases, especially when talking about games, is the edge they provide really enough to justify such an investment?

What’s The Difference?

Put simply, there’s just one difference between mechanical and membrane keyboards: their structure. Mechanical keyboards utilize key switches, whereas membrane keyboards use a three-layer model. These switches register keystrokes when a separate physical mechanism is pressed, resulting in satisfying tactile feedback and a distinct clicky sound. This feedback helps you register a keypress without waiting to see it on the screen, reducing the risk of misinputs.

Mechanical vs. Membrane Keyboards

To anyone who’s done research on what keyboard to get, there’s rarely a case where a membrane keyboard is found superior. Edge cases and certain circumstances aside, a mechanical keyboard almost always provides a better experience. It’s important to keep in mind that you don’t always need an expensive keyboard. Whether or not the amount of money spent is worth the improvement depends entirely on what you wish to do and your preferences.

Typing

If you spend the majority of your time typing, a low-end keyboard might not be good for you. While a mechanical keyboard can 100% make your typing life easier, the difference between a mechanical keyboard vs. high-end membrane keyboards isn’t that much, at least in typing. A mechanical keyboard can provide better feedback and allow for more control over your key presses, but most higher-end membrane keyboards now also provide the latter, so it isn’t that big a factor.

Gaming

Gaming is where the difference starts becoming clearer. For more casual gamers, a membrane keyboard can do the job just fine. However, if you’re a tryhard who needs to do pixel-perfect inputs, even the most expensive membrane keyboards just aren’t built for them. If your main games include fast first-person shooters like Valorant or games that require complex key combinations like DOTA, a mechanical keyboard might be a worthy investment.

How Much Of An Advantage Is There?

I did say mechanical keyboards provide an edge in gaming, but a lot of people overestimate what they do. Or, more specifically, they overestimate their own gaming ability. If you’re not at a rank like Radiant in Valo, chances are the differences would be barely noticeable. It’s only at that top level of play where every millisecond matters that you absolutely need a good mechanical keyboard to stay competitive.

Even if you spend the majority of your time gaming, chances are you won’t be able to utilize the advantage provided by the best keyboards. If you can get the features you want at a lower price point on a better-quality membrane keyboard, a cheaper mechanical keyboard won’t be a good investment. A keyboard only really elevates your gameplay if you cannot improve in other places, i.e. a faster connection or better specs on your PC.

Some Features To Keep An Eye on

Instead of comparing mechanical vs. membrane keyboards, it’d be much better to look for features that can actually smoothen your gameplay. These are:

• Keystroke Latency: It doesn’t matter how fast a tap registers on your keyboard if it doesn’t also go through to the computer. A keyboard with zero debounce, such as the Corsair K100, can provide much better results than a more expensive keyboard with worse latency. 
• Specific Useful Features: If you’re certain what you want a keyboard for, prioritizing those features can help you get your dream keyboard for a lot cheaper. For example, having the Corsair K70 Core‘s control wheel can make video editing a lot easier.

Should You Get A Mechanical Keyboard?

Whether the advantage provided will be worth it or not, all that really matters is preference. I don’t think I really need a mechanical keyboard, but the tactile feedback and the sound of mechanical switches aren’t something I’m comfortable leaving. In the end, performance is only half of the equation; if you like a mechanical keyboard and have the budget for it, you should get it!

Abdul Hannan

[Hardware Reviewer]

After many years of exploiting various pieces of hardware, Abdul Hannan now serves as an editor at Tech4Gamers. He’s been in the PC hardware reviewing industry for almost a decade, and his staff of passionate geeks and reviewers is second to none.

Abdul Hannan is constantly seeking new methods, you will always see him running into New Computer Courses to improve the performance of his computer components since he is an ardent overclocker. He is well-known for providing the most extensive and unbiased analysis of the newest and greatest hardware for PC gaming, including everything from GPUs to PSUs.