Mafia: The Old Country Review Roundup – Great Story, Familiar Flaws

Expert Verified By

One Step Backward, One Step Forward!

Story Highlight
  • Mafia: The Old Country reviews are out.
  • Reviews praise the game’s visuals and narrative, which is still a solid one despite feeling awfully similar.
  • The gameplay falls short, getting repetitive and boring even with the 13-hour gameplay journey.

Just a day ahead of release, the review embargo on Mafia: The Old Country has finally been lifted. While the new entry does take a few steps forward with its changed approach towards a linear narrative, it does take a few steps backward, too.

Aside from the 1900s Sicily setting, not much has changed with the franchise as the latest entry is still a victim of the same old repetitive gameplay that does get boring, even with the short 13-hour gameplay it offers.

Why it matters: 2K Games had a decade to work on the new Mafia game, but they still made the same mistakes that Mafia 3 made. 

mafia old country reviews
Mafia: The Old Country Metacritic Scores

8 – IGN
6 – Game Informer
6 – GameReactor UK
5 – Game Rant
6.5 – Digital Trends

Currently, Mafia: The Old Country holds a 76 score of generally favorable on Metacritic. Most reviewers claim that the game doesn’t reinvent the wheel in any way, despite developers 2k Games claiming they set out to change things for the game.

That said, the game’s visuals are pretty amazing, and 2k Games has done a commendable job in recreating the 1900s Sicily rural setting that feels like an “Italian Holiday,” as said by one reviewer.

The shift to Unreal Engine 5 has also borne some great results with stunning visuals and amazing character models that the series is renowned for.

Moving forward to the narrative, Mafia: The Old Country features a plot many would consider cliche in its genre. There’s nothing different the game has to offer in a classic mob epic, but it’s one worth following through.

Mafia The Old Country
Next Mafia Game Already In The Works

The vocal performances are epic, and the 13-hour journey is well worth following. Most reviewers are divided on the lead, who isn’t that memorable compared to past protagonists like Vito or Tommy.

Gameplay is quite repetitive and boring too, and isn’t much different than Mafia 3 altogether. There’s no depth aside from the typical third-person shooting behind the cover or the basic stealth gameplay.

Nevertheless, Mafia: The Old Country is still a worthwhile game to play, especially with its $50 price tag that will justify its flaws.

Do you plan on buying the game? Let us know in the comments or at the Tech4Gamers Forums.

Was our article helpful? 👨‍💻

Thank you! Please share your positive feedback. 🔋

How could we improve this post? Please Help us. 😔

Gear Up For Latest News

Get exclusive gaming & tech news before it drops. Sign up today!

Join Our Community

Still having issues? Join the Tech4Gamers Forum for expert help and community support!

Latest News

Join Our Community

104,000FansLike
32,122FollowersFollow

Trending

Epic Games Accuses Valve of “Illegal” Methods Over Steam Microtransactions and Fees

Epic Game's CEO accuess Valve, stating that the company still employs excessive commissions and pricing structures that he claims are illegal.

Bethesda Veteran Says Starfield Would’ve Been A Hit If It Was Developed By Some Other Studio

Skyrim lead says if a new, smaller studio developed Starfield, it would've been a hit, because the expectations from Bethesda were too high.

Modders Unlock Multi-Frame Generation Alongside FSR 4, Results Shown On The RX 7900

Modders have now managed to enable FSR 4 and Multi Frame Gen on the 4-year-old RX 7900 and showcased it by running Cyberpunk 2077.

Ex-Rockstar Dev Praises Crimson Desert: “I’m Impressed With The Game”

A former Rockstar developer has reacted to Crimson Desert's latest gameplay, sharing nothing but positive words for the RPG.

Resident Evil Requiem Will Be Less Scary Than RE7, But Still An Improvement Over Village

Resident Evil Requiem director Koshi Nakanishi says that Capcom has toned down the horror in the game since players found RE7 too scary.