RDR 1 Isn’t As Good As People Remember It To Be

Expert Verified By

RDR 1 was a great game, but the lack of screen time for some characters, boring horse riding, and lack of mission variety takes away the fun at times.

Story Highlights
  • Red Dead Redemption 1 does everything great except for some things.
  • One of those things is the lack of mission variety, as almost all missions involve shooting people.
  • The less screen time for some important characters affected the story badly.
  • Horse riding physics also could have been better.

Nostalgia in video games can change one’s opinion of it. Whether the game is good or not, the player will likely be biased towards it if it was a part of their childhood. 

Red Dead Redemption 1 is also one of those games which is considered nostalgic by most players. Due to that reason, it mostly gets positive reviews today. But if you ask someone who has recently played it, you will find a considerable difference in the opinions.

I am not saying Red Dead Redemption 1 is a bad game; it does some things better than its renowned sequel. But if we look at the whole picture, it is not as good as people remember it to be.

A Screenshot From Red Dead Redemption 1
A Screenshot From Red Dead Redemption 1 (Image By Goomba Stomp)

Underwhelming Story

Firstly, the story and the characters needed a bit more work. If you have played Red Dead Redemption 2 first and then the prequel, you may have no complaints regarding the story. However, the story may feel boring if you do not know the characters’ backgrounds and backstories.

Don’t get me wrong—it has a pretty decent story, but it wasn’t as good as the reviews I heard before playing it. The story takes place after the events of Red Dead Redemption 2 and is based on John’s revenge, in which the government was also involved, in some way, against his former gang, especially their leader, Dutch van der Linde.

John kills every last member of the gang, including the Dutch. In the end, the government kills him and his wife, and only his son, Jack, survives. The story progresses slowly and dramatically, giving John enough time to enter the players’ hearts with his badass personality. But for other players, the screen time isn’t enough.

Not Enough Screen Time For Some Characters

The gang members deserved more time than they got, as they were incredible characters. That is even more applicable to Dutch as his character is one of the best in the franchise, and he barely has enough time to shine and make an impression.

Dutch van der Linde Death Scene
Dutch van der Linde Death Scene (Image By Red Dead Wiki)

Again, if you already know these characters, you would not need more time for them to understand their personalities better. 

The story should have focused more on these characters to make them relevant. The overall story certainly revolved around them, but with less screen time, their characters got buried.

Clunky Gameplay

The gameplay was also quite clunky and lacked the fun element. The ragdoll physics and the shooting are amazing, though, especially when you shoot an NPC on the shoulder, and they get turned around by the bullet’s force and fall to the ground, just like the old Wild West movies.

However, other than these things, I believe there wasn’t much to the gameplay. The horse riding was boring, and the animations looked bad at times. The physics was also weird for horse riding as whenever you are riding at a high speed and come across an obstacle, the horse doesn’t react to the object and suddenly stops.

This breaks the whole momentum and takes the fun away from horse riding. You also can’t do much with your horse except ride it, but I won’t complain about that much because there’s a technology barrier.

Horse riding in rdr1
byu/KlademD inreddeadredemption

Missions Needed More Variety

The missions also lack variety. Almost all missions feel the same. You have to shoot down people, which is fun, but some variety would have greatly improved the gameplay. The story has some interesting side missions, but their gameplay element could have been improved. 

The maps feel empty, as there isn’t much to look at. Most of the map is just plain land; we do see some mountains in Mexico, though. 

Final Verdict

Despite all the bad things, Red Dead Redemption 1 still does many things correctly. The side activities are fun, including shows, duels, poker, Ler’s dice, and more. It isn’t much compared to Red Dead Redemption 2, but it is still enough for its time. The gun shooting is also fun and is done pretty well in terms of physics and animations.

Was our article helpful? 👨‍💻

Thank you! Please share your positive feedback. 🔋

How could we improve this post? Please Help us. 😔

Join Our Community

Still having issues? Join the Tech4Gamers Forum for expert help and community support!

Latest News

Join Our Community



Hunter x Hunter: Nen Impact Brings Back The Joy Of PS2 Fighters

Hunter x Hunter: Nen Impact's cell-shaded graphics and simple to grasp game mechanics brings back the feel of PS2 fighters.

How Shuffle Time Can Shape Persona 6 Gameplay

Learn how the potential return of shuffle time in Persona 6 can influence the overall gameplay and peak the interest of Persona fans.

Esports And Pro-Gaming: The Rise of Competitive Gaming

Esports and pro-gaming are soaring industries with many taking to gaming as a profession, however the industry is batteling oversaturation.

These Builds Will Make Shadow of The Erdtree Way Easier For You

Shadow of the Erdtree is criticized for being difficult, but these builds make the DLC a completely unexpected cakewalk.

The Impact of Half-Life: Alyx on VR Gaming

Half-Life: Alyx is one of the most immersive, story-rich, realistic VR game that has set the bar so high that it might not be surpassed.